Massachusetts Town Faces Accusations over Potentially Illegal Background Checks

By Michael Klazema on 9/16/2016

The town of Webster, Massachusetts is searching for a new town administrator. The search process involves a committee of people and detailed background checks for top potential candidates. However, according to a report from the Telegram & Gazette—a newspaper based in Worcester—there is some question regarding the legality of the background checks.

The Telegram & Gazette report noted that Webster's Town Administrator Screening Committee has helped to whittle the candidate field down to three finalists. The town's Board of Selection will screen and interview those three finalists to arrive at a hiring decision. But townspeople and members of the screening committee are concerned that the Board of Selection might not be completely objective in its assessment of new candidates. In particular, some people in the town of Webster believe that the board is intentionally skewing the process in favor of the sitting town administrator.

One of the areas of concern in the screening process is a "waiver of liability form" that all candidates must sign. This form permits the town to run extensive background checks on each finalist. Two finalists who were recently eliminated from the town administrator search took issue with the form, which has not been revised in 17 years.

Webster's waiver of liability form does not just give the town the right to run criminal background checks or employment verifications on applicants. By signing the form, the finalists for the town administrator position are asked to waive clergy-penitent privilege and consent to a thorough health investigation.

Waiving clergy-penitent privilege would feasibly allow the town of Webster to interview priests about confessions that the finalists may have made in the past. Typically, anything said to a member of the clergy in confession is privileged information. Like attorney-client privilege or doctor-patient confidentiality, this bond between "clergy" and "penitent" is typically maintained without exceptions. Webster's waiver of liability form requires town administrator candidates to waive that privilege or be disqualified from consideration.

Webster's request for town administrator candidates to waive clergy-penitent privilege is unusual but it isn't illegal. What may be illegal is the town's request to delve into the current health and medical histories of candidates. The Telegram & Gazette report noted that this part of the waiver of liability form may violate HIPAA (the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996) and its "Privacy Rule." At least one member of the Town Administrator Screening Committee wants to hire an outside legal consultant to determine whether or not Webster is violating federal law. If the waiver of liability form violates HIPAA, the town may need to revamp its background check policies before filling the administrator position.


Industry News

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • December 11 The Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Inspector General criticized a migrant youth detention center on the border for not running the proper background checks. Federal law requires the facility to screen all employees with FBI fingerprint checks.
  • December 06 In a bid to combat money laundering and illicit funding sources for terrorists flowing through the country's real estate sector, Singapore's government now mandates background checks for buyers purchasing properties prior to development.
  • December 04 What is a reference check? How does it vary from a work history check? We explore these questions and others.
  • December 04 Chicago Public Schools has dismissed hundreds of employees, coaches, vendors, and volunteers based on background check findings. The district recently vowed to re-check the majority of its 68,000 employees after a Chicago Tribune investigation revealed holes in its background check policies.
  • November 29 Striving to create a safer environment more conducive to productive training and leadership development, the Army has recently moved to adopt a uniform policy of background checks for certain roles. 
  • November 27 For hiring managers to verify the information provided on a resume, verification is essential.  Such is the purpose of employment history background checks.
  • November 27 California’s biggest public school district is waiving the cost of volunteer background checks. The move is meant to encourage more family - and community members to get involved with the school district.
  • November 22 Contractors play an important role in the workforce, delivering services to both individuals and organizations. Vetting contractors for suitability continues to be a challenge, as two recent articles prove.
  • November 21 When it comes to background and pre-employment checks, it can be instructive to look at the characteristics of the ten most massive U.S. employers.
  • November 21

    Verification checks are a powerful way to assess how truthful a job candidate has been on his or her application or resume. These checks can verify work history, education verification, professional licenses, and favorable personal qualities.