European High Court Sends Safe Harbor Swirling

By Michael Klazema on 9/28/2015

The news is not wholly unexpected, as the opinion taps into widely held concerns about the US sector-based approach data protection, which stands in contrast to the European view of privacy as a fundamental human right. A final ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) is expected in three months.

The High Court opinion stems from a case brought by an Austrian Facebook user against the Data Protection Commissioner for Ireland and rejects the original findings. Maximillian Schrems, an Austrian national living in Austria, has taken exception to a Facebook policy that requires EU citizens to allow some or all of their data to be transferred from Ireland (the location of FB EU servers) to its servers in the US.

But it is Edward Snowden, not Facebook, who was the catalyst for this complaint. Following Snowden revelations around US intelligence programs, Schrems in 2013 lodged a complaint with the Irish Data Commissioner, maintaining that US data protection schemes effectively offer no safeguards against unfettered “State Surveillance.”

The data commissioner dismissed the complaint as frivolous, noting there was no evidence to indicate that Facebook or the US intelligence agencies had accessed his data, and further deciding that US Safe Harbor scheme provided adequate data protection.

Schrems took his complaint to the European High Court for a preliminary ruling. The court agreed that Snowden revelations raised significant concerns about the “mass indiscriminate surveillance and interception” of data.

In the opinion of the Advocate General, Safe Harbor fails to provide adequate protection to EU citizens because there is no means to measure or monitor compliance (Safe Harbor is a voluntary certification program) and EU citizens have no voice in how their data is used. He called for an EU-style Data Protection Authority (DPA) as a potential remedy to ensure adequate controls.

What You Should Do:

  • Await further news and developments. There will be no determination for at least three months, although we expect extended debate in the meantime. Safe Harbor remains intact; even if the High Court opinion stands, that does not signal the end to cross-border data flow. There are model contracts endorsed by the European Union that can be put in place to confer adequacy in US-EU data transfers.
  • Review the high court opinion, which is available at;?docid=168421&doclang=en

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • January 15 A viral news story at The Cleveland Clinic has reignited the debate over social media background checks. The hospital recently fired a medical resident with a history of anti-Semitic tweets.
  • January 10 To remain a competitive employment option for retail workers, Best Buy will begin offering childcare options for parents. 
  • January 07 The rise of the "gig economy" was rapid, and questions about safety for users of these new services grew along with the industry. Background check policies in the gig economy can be unclear or unevenly applied, leading to barriers for some seeking jobs.
  • January 04 A new service that offers background checks for babysitters has come under fire for racial bias, invasion of privacy, and non-compliance with FCRA requirements. Predictim has paused its launch due to controversy.
  • December 20 Trust between patient and practitioner is a critical part of a strong healthcare system. An investigation uncovered hundreds of doctors practicing in new locations after giving up their licenses following serious mistakes.
  • December 13

    As the food truck fad proves it has staying power, many local governments have looked for ways to protect their communities without constraining economic activity. The effort to strike the right balance is ongoing.

  • December 11 The Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Inspector General criticized a migrant youth detention center on the border for not running the proper background checks. Federal law requires the facility to screen all employees with FBI fingerprint checks.
  • December 11 What are education verification checks and why are they important? We look at why and how employers confirm the education histories of the people they hire.
  • December 06 In a bid to combat money laundering and illicit funding sources for terrorists flowing through the country's real estate sector, Singapore's government now mandates background checks for buyers purchasing properties prior to development.
  • December 04 What is a reference check? How does it vary from a work history check? We explore these questions and others.