Youth Sports Leagues Navigate Challenges in Wake of Nasser Scandal

By Michael Klazema on 7/25/2019

In the years since the news broke of a sexual abuse scandal so widespread that it rocked USA Gymnastics to its core, parents across the country have cast a wary eye towards youth sports organizations. Tales of USA Gymnastics doctor Larry Nasser abusing young girls for years have led many parents to wonder how they can trust that their children will be safe under the tutelage of coaches.  

While some observers wondered if gymnastics could survive such a scandal, for the operators of local clubs in Iowa, the answer was never in doubt—and their attendance numbers remain strong. 

Club owners say that local parents have differentiated between the failings of the national organization and the safety efforts long underway at locations in Iowa. Background checks, similar to the US OneSEARCH offered by, form the foundation of the vetting process that these clubs use, but in-depth interviews and smart policy making play a role, too. For example, club rules limit contact outside of approved practice times, and no adult may ever be left alone with a child.  

An opinion piece in Forbes points out that while due diligence can help to protect children, it is not a guarantee of safety. According to the author, only a handful of states require background checks for activities such as non-school-related sports. Many local youth leagues that vet adults working with children only use local or state-level background checks. In contrast, the author points out, Little League International recently expanded its process to use national background checks. The League notes that its new system has some shortcomings but provides better coverage than before.  

Background checks aren't predictive of future behavior: individuals with otherwise clean records may still commit crimes after their hiring. There will always be a need for oversight within youth sports organizations combined with a culture that emphasizes the importance of "see something, say something" behavior. The active role in policing the activities of coaches and students on display in Iowa is an example of how the most important component in any vetting strategy is accountability. 

That's an area in which critics claim that another national sports organization, USA Swimming, is lagging.  

Multiple reports reveal that USA Swimming has been part of numerous sexual harassment cases in which young swimmers were abused by coaches who dodged background checks or misrepresented themselves. With no galvanizing moment such as the Nasser trial, the organization has tried to manage the situation through policy revisions to implement restrictions similar to those in Iowa.  

Youth sports should be an opportunity for children and teenagers to explore their abilities and develop their skills. For that to be true, adults must assume full responsibility for making these organizations as safe as possible. Sensible policies are a solid first step, and backing them with robust vetting is the next. enables youth sports organizations to more easily conduct their due diligence with tailored reporting packages designed with their specific needs in mind. As the shock waves from the Nasser scandal subside, it's crucial for sports organizations across the country to come away from it with the right lessons.

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • August 15 Background checks aren't a silver bullet that solves every concern about prospective new hires—they are a tool that must be used with care. How can an incorrect approach lead to inadequate vetting? 
  • August 13 How has legislation and regulation changed the way employers use criminal background checks? We look at some of the rules that modern companies must follow.
  • August 08 With many industries facing labor shortages, advocates and legislatures are reconsidering policies that exclude potential employees. Expansion of record expungement and "ban the box" rules could change the system. 
  • August 06 Continuous background screening or ongoing criminal monitoring is the best way to keep track of critical new developments on an employee’s criminal record. Learn how these background checks work. 
  • August 01

    A new lawsuit filed in New York alleges that department store chain Macy’s ignored federal hiring guidelines and laws, firing individuals for old and non-job-related criminal convictions. 


  • July 30 The Minneapolis City Council is considering a series of ordinances that would regulate the use of tenant background checks and security deposits. The city’s tight housing market has made it difficult for individuals with bad credit, eviction histories, or criminal records to find housing.
  • July 25 Following revelations about wrongdoing in USA Gymnastics at the hands of team doctor Larry Nasser, sports organizations must grapple with how to safeguard their members. Some have found more success than others. 
  • July 24 What do landlords want to know before accepting new tenants? Here are the basics included in the average tenant background check.
  • July 23 7-Eleven will pay nearly $2 million to settle a class-action lawsuit concerning its background check process. The lawsuit alleges that the convenience store chain violated the FCRA with its background check disclosure document.
  • July 22 Social and child service organization rely on background checks to vet employees, sponsors, drivers, and other staff members and volunteers. By helping to root out histories of violence, sexual abuse, and other red flags, our resources assist these organizations in keeping the people they serve safe.