University of Maryland Moves Toward a Broader Background Check Policy

By Michael Klazema on 3/12/2020

For college administrators nationwide, protecting and enhancing on-campus safety are two of the most pressing tasks. With significant incidents within the past decade still looming, including the Larry Nassar and Jerry Sandusky abuse scandals, university systems are grappling with questions about how to best protect their students. In Maryland, the state's flagship university has put background checks for staff at the top of its to-do list.

In a bill currently under consideration by the University of Maryland's Senate, background checks similar to the US OneSEARCH offered by would become a hiring requirement. The rules would apply to support roles such as administrative assistants and teaching roles, from adjuncts to associate professors. 

Currently, the university's policy does not go beyond the state mandate for vetting specific job duties, such as background checks for professionals working with children. Of the 12 schools under the University System of Maryland's umbrella, ten already require background checks for some or all faculty and staff positions on campus. 

Sponsors of the bill say that it is one piece of a larger strategy to create a safer environment for students. Some faculty members have expressed doubts about the efficacy of such a policy, wondering whether it could inject bias into UMD's hiring process.

Across academia, background checks have found popularity as a first line of defense for protecting students from harm. However, though they may be a valuable aid in identifying individuals who could pose a risk, they cannot predict future behavior. Ongoing criminal monitoring identifies problems that occur after hiring. Still, this useful tool is not a substitute for clearly-defined policies for addressing misconduct and an organizational culture that encourages following procedure.

The alternative has played out across many campuses with universities facing the consequences of issues from oversights to organized cover-ups. At the University of Michigan, faculty members reportedly raised concerns about the hiring of a high-profile individual who later faced accusations of sexual harassment and misconduct. The Omaha World-Herald also reported on two known instances of abuse at UM that went unpunished by administrators. 

When policies break down at the upper levels of an organization, the potential for harm increases dramatically. While academia background checks are tools to promote safety on the ground floor, well-developed policies and better enforcement enhance their effectiveness. Screening an employee's suitability shouldn't end on his or her first day of work.

Should UMD adopt the new rules, the school will face a challenge that many other organizations struggle with today: how to keep time-to-hire reasonable without compromising on vetting requirements. The proper tools from, from criminal history reports to reference checks, can help reduce delays. 

By providing hiring managers with the appropriate information, organizations including many of America's universities hope to create a safer space for their staff and students.

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • April 02 Advocates of fair hiring say that "ban the box" laws aid individuals with criminal records in finding work. Some studies suggest that they may have the opposite effect.
  • March 31 Georgia is one step closer to rewriting its expungement laws thanks to the State Senate’s unanimous approval of a piece of reform legislation. The law, if passed, would make more ex-offenders in the state eligible to petition for expungement.
  • March 26 Advocacy for "second chance" policies have led to broad changes for employers, but landlords could see fundamental shifts, too. Is there a developing trend of disallowing tenant background checks? 
  • March 24

    Devising an internal policy for employee background checks is a hurdle that all organizations must face. Here’s how to balance your employment process with legal requirements.

  • March 24 Regarding background checks for actors, the process varies by production company, film, or even role. Lesser-known actors filling supporting roles or stepping in as extras may be subject to standard temporary worker background checks.
  • March 19

    With the growth of "ban the box" laws and the contraction of the labor pool, the modern workforce has changed. Ongoing monitoring solutions are a vital tool in this new environment.

  • March 17 Every organization must provide a safe environment for the people it employs and serves. One West Virginia church's extensive efforts showcase the importance of well-defined protocols in creating safer spaces.
  • March 17 Landlords use a variety of tools to vet rental applicants before offering them a lease agreement. We explore whether evictions appear on the criminal history reports often used by property managers.
  • March 12 Choosing to go beyond its legal requirements, UMD may soon require background checks for all positions in the university. Some opponents question the necessity for such a policy. 
  • March 10 Handing over your passport at United States border crossing is a standard part of entry procedures, but what can border agents do with that info? We investigate background checks at border control.