Before You Pause a Placed Worker Over a Background Check: The Staffing Agency's Steps
September 10th, 2020
Updated November 17, 2026
Update. In a press release dated October 29, 2026, the EEOC announced that it voted to rescind its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII. The rescission is effective immediately. Title VII, state and local fair chance laws, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) still apply.
The EEOC said the rescission does not require employers to abandon lawful practices they adopted in response to the guidance. It removes one federal guidance document. It does not change Title VII, the FCRA or any state or city fair chance law. This page explains what changed, what did not, and what to update in your own process.
The EEOC rescinded one document: its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII. Here is what the agency's own records say.
The rescission. The EEOC's October 29, 2026 press release says the Commission voted to rescind the guidance and that the rescission is effective immediately.
How the vote happened. The EEOC had scheduled a public meeting for October 30, 2026 to consider the rescission (91 FR 67312). It later published a notice that the Commissioners decided the matter by notation vote and canceled the meeting (91 FR 69255).
No return to older policy. The EEOC said the rescission does not restore the policy statements that the 2012 guidance replaced.
No order to drop practices. The EEOC said the rescission does not "require employers to abandon any lawful practices they may have adopted in response to it."
Title VII. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 still bars employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex and national origin (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2). In the same release, EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas said that Title VII continues to prohibit discrimination based on race or national origin, including employment requirements that are proxies for intentional discrimination.
Disparate impact is in the statute. Under Title VII, if a person shows that a practice causes a disparate impact, the employer must show the practice is "job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity" (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k)). Congress added that text to Title VII in 1991. The rescission did not change it.
Private lawsuits. Title VII lets the person claiming to be aggrieved bring a civil action after filing a charge with the EEOC and receiving notice from it (42 U.S.C. 2000e-5(f)(1)). A change in EEOC guidance does not change that right.
State and local fair chance laws. States, counties and cities set their own rules on when and how employers can consider criminal history. The rescission did not change any of them. Examples follow below.
The FCRA. The FCRA's disclosure and authorization steps before you order a report, and its notice steps before and after adverse action, are in the statute (15 U.S.C. 1681b(b)(2) and (b)(3) and 15 U.S.C. 1681m). The EEOC rescission did not touch them. See our guide to adverse action and our FCRA compliance checklist for employers.
Federal guidance was never the only rule. In many places, state and city law decides when you can ask about records and what you must do before you act on them. Three examples:
Washington. Unless an exception applies, an employer may not ask about or obtain an applicant's criminal record until after it decides the applicant is otherwise qualified and makes a conditional offer (RCW 49.94.010). The conditional offer rule applies to employers with 15 or more employees from July 1, 2026, and to smaller employers from January 1, 2027. The law's definition of employer includes temporary staffing agencies and employment agencies (RCW 49.94.005). See our Washington guide.
New York City. The city's amended Fair Chance rules took effect October 30, 2026 (NYC Commission on Human Rights). See our post on the NYC Fair Chance Act rules for employers and staffing agencies and our New York guide.
California. The state's Fair Chance Act took effect January 1, 2018. It generally bars employers with five or more employees from asking about conviction history before a job offer (California Civil Rights Department). See our California guide.
Other state guides that cover local rules: Illinois, Colorado, Oregon, Massachusetts and New Jersey. For a state-by-state view of timing rules, see our ban the box overview.
Use the rescission as a reason to review your written policy. Work through these steps with your counsel.
Find every citation to the 2012 guidance. Check your screening policy, recruiter training, client playbooks and adjudication notes. Replace "per EEOC guidance" with the law that actually applies: Title VII, the FCRA, and the state and local rules where you hire.
Keep job-related criteria for each role. Title VII's own test is whether a practice is "job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity." Write down which records matter for which jobs, and why.
Avoid blanket bans. A rule that excludes everyone with any record is the kind of policy most often cited in disparate impact claims. In Washington, the law expressly bars policies that automatically or categorically exclude people with a record (RCW 49.94.010(3)).
Keep your timing rules by location. Where state or city law sets when you can order a check, keep ordering at that point. The rescission did not move any of those dates.
Keep your FCRA steps. Do not remove disclosure, authorization or adverse action steps because the EEOC guidance is gone. They come from a different law. See what disclosures applicants sign and our guide to adverse action.
Keep reviewing records case by case where local law requires it. Some state and city laws require their own review before you act on a conviction. For example, Washington requires an employer to tell the person which record it is relying on before it acts (RCW 49.94.010). New York City requires its Fair Chance Employment Analysis and Process (NYC Commission on Human Rights rules). Check the rules where you hire.
Document each decision. Records of how you applied your policy help if a decision is ever challenged.
For staffing agencies: the rules that apply can depend on where a worker is placed, and some fair chance laws name employment agencies directly (RCW 49.94.005). Keep one screening profile per client and location, and recheck it when you open a new market. Our guide to a client-ready screening program and our staffing and recruiting agencies page cover how.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 created the EEOC, which opened on July 2, 1965. Its role in how employers use background checks came later, as more employers began screening candidates.
Title VII does not ban background checks. As the 2012 guidance put it, "Having a criminal record is not listed as a protected basis in Title VII." The focus has been on how employers use criminal records, and whether a policy treats people differently or screens out protected groups at higher rates.
Title VII recognizes two kinds of claims that can apply to criminal record screening. Disparate treatment means treating applicants differently because of a protected characteristic, such as disqualifying applicants of one race for a conviction while letting applicants of another race with the same conviction move forward. Disparate impact means a neutral-looking policy that screens out a protected group at a higher rate. A blanket policy that excludes everyone with any criminal record is the common example.
This section describes guidance the EEOC rescinded, effective immediately, as announced in its press release dated October 29, 2026. It is here for background. It is not current EEOC guidance.
The 2012 guidance explained how the EEOC applied Title VII disparate treatment and disparate impact to arrest and conviction records.
It listed three factors, often called the Green factors, as relevant to whether a criminal record exclusion was job related for the position and consistent with business necessity:
The nature and gravity of the offense or conduct.
The time that has passed since the offense or conduct and/or completion of the sentence.
The nature of the job held or sought.
It also described individualized assessment: giving people excluded by a screen a chance to show why the exclusion should not apply to them. It said Title VII "does not necessarily require individualized assessment in all circumstances" but that it "can help employers avoid Title VII liability."
Trusted by over 100,000 companies. You decide when to order, so your team can send the check at the point each state or city requires. Our platform walks your team through applicant authorization, screening and adverse action letters, with human support when you need it. Need help setting up packages by role or by client? Contact our team. For an outside review of the platform, read the TechRadar review of BackgroundChecks.com.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws change and vary by state and city. Consult your attorney about your hiring practices.
Need Background Checks?
See packages and pricing and order instantly.
National, County, Statewide, Federal Criminal Searches
Motor Vehicle Records
Employment & Education Verifications
Bankruptcies, Liens, & Judgments
Drug Testing
Before You Pause a Placed Worker Over a Background Check: The Staffing Agency's Steps
NYC Fair Chance Act 2026 Rules: What Employers and Staffing Agencies Should Check
New: Identity Verification and Civil Court Searches for Employers
Warehouse Staffing Background Checks: Package the Assignment, Not the Person
AI in Background Screening: Faster Hires Without the Compliance Risk
HireRight vs. BackgroundChecks.com: Which Background Screening Platform Fits Your Business?
Background Check Pricing in 2026: What You Should Expect to Pay (and How to Avoid Hidden Fees)
Resources
Background Checks