West Virginia Seeks to Hold Catholic Church Accountable for Abuse

By Michael Klazema on 4/4/2019

New allegations about abuse at the hands of priests and others within Catholic diocese across the country has elicited renewed scrutiny from state lawmakers and law enforcement officials nationwide as they seek ways to hold accountable those responsible for a litany of alleged crimes. Broad criminal cases have been few and far between with scattered individual prosecutions often hampered by statutes of limitations and other complicating factors. However, the attorney general of West Virginia believes he has found a way to enforce some accountability through the use of a unique civil suit.

In late March, AG Patrick Morrisey filed a lawsuit with one of the state's Catholic diocese in the crosshairs. Rather than attempting a criminal prosecution, Morrisey's suit alleges that the Catholic Church violated rules outlined in West Virginia's Consumer Credit and Protection Act, a law intended to safeguard consumers from unscrupulous companies. The suit alleges that the Wheeling-Charleston diocese failed to follow proper procedure for conducting background checks and went as far as to employ individuals known to have previously committed sex crimes.

The suit alleges that the Church regularly failed to carry out legally-required background checks, similar to the multi-jurisdictional US OneSEARCH provided by, even when applicants disclosed accusations of previous crimes. Instead, West Virginia says the diocese merely relied on the word of officials from the priest's previous diocese. Even members of the laity who applied for work within the diocese did not receive background checks. In one case, a priest who had confessed to abusing children was placed for work within one of the area's Catholic elementary schools.

West Virginia contends that the Church violated the consumer protection law. The state is seeking a variety of penalties, including mandatory changes to the diocese policies and severe financial consequences for both the Bishop and the diocese for every violation of the law. 

Legal experts hailed the move as a groundbreaking way to explore new opportunities for penalizing the Church for its misdeeds while religious officials contend that such laws cannot apply to the Church as it is not a business. While the outcome of this lawsuit remains to be seen, the allegations and facts laid out within the court filings offer a stunning view of the consequences that can arise from systemic failures in an organization's approach to background checks. 

For churches and other religious organizations, safety begins with fully understanding the backgrounds of individuals that they hire. To facilitate that understanding, provides a solution custom tailored to meet the unique needs of these groups. We roll our US OneSEARCH, employment and reference verification, and other products into one package that makes handling these serious responsibilities less stressful. Discover today how these tools can help create the safe spaces religious organizations strive to represent. 

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • April 23 A property management company hired a maintenance worker last fall because her background check came back clean. In reality, she had convictions for identity theft, drug possession, forgery, and more.
  • April 18 Riding the wave of ban the box rules passed in many states and cities, the Senate and House of Representatives will consider permanent rules for federal employment. 
  • April 16 A recent audit of Ottawa’s leasing office found that the department isn’t properly managing the leasing process. Among the issues was a lack of background checks for new lessees.
  • April 16 Uber is redefining the way we get around, especially in urban areas. What are the company’s policies for driver background checks?
  • April 12 Staffing agencies need a dependable way to vet their candidates, find red flags, and weed out hires who might pose a threat to the businesses that the agency serves. Many staffing companies rely on to fill this critical employee screening need. Here are just a few that have discovered the quality and reliability of screening services.
  • April 11

    The employment world is a constantly-evolving organism driven by everything from technological leaps forward to shifts in culture. Read our ten enterprise-focused trends that SMBs should expect to encounter and contend with in 2019.

  • April 11 Seeking to expand housing availability in a region characterized by shortages, Portland’s City Council will consider new rules concerning how landlords screen and reject potential tenants.
  • April 09 San Joaquin County in California has recorded four sexual misconduct cases involving local youth sports programs in the past month alone. The cases highlight the importance of background checks in youth sporting organizations.
  • April 09 Which background checks are required for teachers? There are differing state and school policies for teacher background checks.
  • April 04 Seeking a way to hold the Catholic Church responsible for alleged abuse, West Virginia has taken a unique approach: suing using a law meant for consumer protection.