Tennessee Grants Negligent Hiring Immunity

By Michael Klazema on 7/11/2014

The Tennessee legislature recently enacted Senate Bill 276, which establishes section 107 of the Criminal Procedure Code Title 40, Chapter 29. Chapter 29 deals with the restoration of citizenship for persons convicted of infamous or felony crimes and were deprived of the rights of citizenship by judgment of a state or federal court. Section 107 was created so that individuals applying to have citizenship restored may also petition the court for a certificate of employability. Effective July 1, 2014, employers are granted immunity from liability for hiring individuals with a certificate of employability, in some circumstances.

When a court receives an individual’s petition for a certificate of employability, it must review the petition, the person’s criminal history, filings submitted by a district attorney, United States attorney, or victim of crimes perpetrated by the petitioner, and all other relevant evidence. The court may issue a certificate of employability, at its discretion, if it finds that the person has established all of the following:

  1. The petitioner has been a person of honesty, respectability, and veracity, and is generally esteemed as such by his or her neighbors;
  2. Granting the petition will materially assist the person in obtaining employment or occupational licensing;
  3. The person has a substantial need for the relief requested in order to live a law-abiding life; and
  4. Granting the petition would not pose an unreasonable risk to the safety of the public or any individual.

If an individual presents a valid certificate of employability, then Tennessee occupational licenses and certificates will not automatically be denied issuance, restoration, or renewal based solely on a person’s past criminal history. Instead, consideration will be given on a case-by-case basis whether to grant or deny an occupational license when an individual presents a certificate of employability.

A certificate of employability may be used as evidence of an employer’s due care in hiring in defense of a legal or administrative proceeding if the employer knew of the certificate at the time of the alleged negligence or other fault. However, there is no immunity if all of the following apply:

  1. The employee demonstrates danger or is convicted of a felony after being hired;
  2. The employer retains the person as an employee after the demonstration of danger or the conviction;
  3. The plaintiff proves that the person with hiring and firing responsibility for the employer had actual knowledge that the employee was dangerous or had been convicted of a felony; and
  4. The employer, after having actual knowledge of the employee’s demonstration of danger or conviction of a felony, was willful in retaining the person as an employee.

The provisions of the new law do not apply to individuals or entities subject to licensing, certification, or regulation by any board, commission, or agency for police officers, correctional institutions, and individuals in the mental health, education, insurance, healing arts, or welfare industries.

Tennessee’s Public Chapter No. 815 is available here:

Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • May 18 In search of more personnel and considering normalization, some major employers have elected to drop pre-employment drug screens for marijuana. As the opioid epidemic continues, there is still a role for workplace drug tests.
  • May 15

    A Congressional IT contractor who is facing bank fraud, a class-action lawsuit, and allegations of cyber breach never underwent a background check. Congressional guidelines recommend background screenings but have a loophole that makes it possible to skip them.

  • May 10 Are SSN background checks essential, or even necessary? We look at what Social Security Number data can and cannot do in the background check process.
  • May 10

    In the wake of an attack in which the perpetrator used a rental vehicle to strike pedestrians, and with a growing number of such attacks around the world in recent years, rental companies must consider how to address the issue. Effective security measures have proven difficult to implement.

  • May 08 Some statistics suggest employers aren’t running international background checks. In a job market where foreign candidates are increasingly common, this oversight can be dangerous.
  • May 03

    Despite player numbers in the millions, the primary sanctioning body for youth soccer in the United States established no standard policy requiring background checks. They face legal jeopardy due to the actions of abusive coaches. 

  • May 03 Are you applying for a job with Starbucks? Here’s what to expect from the background check process.
  • May 02 — Further restrictions have been placed on employers that inquire about prior criminal records. Timeframes have been adjusted and asking about expunged records is prohibited. 
  • May 01 Uber is expanding its background check policies. Going forward, the company will incorporate repeat background checks and ongoing criminal monitoring into its driver screening processes.
  • April 28 Airport background checks are governed by the TSA and FAA. They typically include employment history checks, criminal history searches, and a few other elements.