Background Check on a City Award Recipient Controversy

The controversy surrounding background checks on city award recipients has ignited a public debate. Specifically, Mayor Stefan Roots’ decision to conduct background screening on such a recipient in Chester City brought significant attention to the issue. Personal privacy is a serious concern when conducting employment background checks.

The Impact of Publicizing Background Checks on Individuals

Publicly sharing background checks can harm employees or potential candidates significantly. When a criminal background check is made public, it can:

  • Ruin someone’s reputation
  • Cause social stigma
  • Result in job loss

Even if the information is old or irrelevant, the person may still face unfair judgment.

Ethical Considerations

Finding the right balance between transparency in hiring and respecting privacy rights requires careful ethical scrutiny. Employers need to consider two key factors:

  1. Transparency: Making sure hiring decisions are fair and based on accurate information.
  2. Privacy: Safeguarding individuals from unnecessary harm and preserving their self-respect.

Best Practices for Employers: Respecting Applicants’ Privacy During Background Screening

Employers have strict legal obligations when they conduct background checks. You need to follow laws such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), which requires written permission from applicants before doing a background check. The FCRA also demands that if an employer plans to take adverse action based on the background check, you must give the applicant a copy of the report and a summary of their rights.

Two essential government agencies, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), make sure that employers are fair and legal when they do background checks:

  • EEOC: Enforces federal laws against employment discrimination. They make sure that background checks don’t unfairly affect minority groups.
  • FTC: Watches over companies to make sure they follow the FCRA. They check that consumer reporting agencies have accurate information and protect people’s privacy.

Here are the expectations from employers:

  1. Have clear policies explaining how they’ll do background checks.
  2. Make sure these policies follow federal laws.
  3. Regularly check and update these policies when there are new laws.

Following these best practices helps employers obtain the necessary information while respecting applicants’ privacy.

Character References and Drug Testing

Employers can gain valuable insights about candidates’ suitability by using alternative methods to traditional background checks. One effective approach is assessing job performance through practical tasks or simulations relevant to the role. This method focuses on actual skills and competencies, providing a clearer picture of a candidate’s ability to perform specific job functions.

Conducting interviews with previous employers or colleagues can also offer in-depth information about an applicant’s work ethic, reliability, and interpersonal skills. These character references often reveal more nuanced details that standard background checks might miss.

To protect sensitive information obtained during these processes:

  • Implement comprehensive privacy policies outlining how data will be collected, used, and stored.
  • Use secure data management systems to ensure that personal information remains confidential and is only accessible to authorized personnel.

In addition to these methods, workplace drug testing can be essential to the screening process. However, it must be conducted discreetly and respectfully to maintain the individual’s dignity. Limiting access to test results and ensuring they are shared only with relevant decision-makers minimizes the risk of public exposure.

These practices balance the need for thorough employment decisions with respecting candidates’ privacy rights.

Minimizing the Risk of Public Exposure: Strategies for Employers

Background Screening Services

Employers can adopt several strategies to minimize the risk of public exposure for individuals who undergo background screening:

  • Limit access to results: To prevent the unnecessary dissemination of sensitive information, restrict access to background check results by sharing them only with relevant decision-makers.
  • Confidential handling: Implement protocols for confidential handling of background check data. Ensure that all personnel involved understand the importance of maintaining privacy.
  • Secure Storage Systems: Utilize secure data management systems to store background check information. Encryption and restricted access controls can protect against unauthorized access and data breaches.

Drug Testing

Privacy in Drug Testing

  • Discreet drug testing: Conduct workplace drug testing discreetly and respectfully. Designate private areas for sample collection and ensure that medical personnel follow strict confidentiality guidelines.
  • Clear communication: An unambiguous explanation of drug testing purposes and procedures to employees and candidates fosters trust and reduces anxiety.

Publicized background checks can profoundly impact individuals’ lives, potentially damaging reputations and causing undue stigma. Employers must balance transparency in employment background screening decisions and protect job seekers from discrimination.

Adopting the best practices outlined in this article will help ensure fair and responsible use in terms of background check privacy laws.


Get instant updates on Background Screening 101

Michael Klazema

About Michael Klazema The author

Michael Klazema is the lead author and editor for Dallas-based with a focus on human resource and employment screening developments

Michael's recent publications

More Like This Post

State Criminal Search

Virginia Criminal Search

A Virginia state background check can uncover more criminal records. Learn about these tools and the legal restrictions involved.

Order a Search for Virginia