Are Background Checks Effective?

By Michael Klazema on 5/14/2019

How effective are background checks?

While background checks are a standard part of the pre-employment screening process,   employers might question how useful they are. Say your business conducts a background check and misses a red flag in a candidate’s past. In this case, you might start to feel disillusioned about background checks. How effective can background checks be if you rely on them but they fail to give you pertinent information?

The important thing to realize is that not all background checks are effective. The simple act of running a background check on a job candidate won’t find every piece of information about that person’s past. Instead, you will need to do a little more work to make sure that your background check is thorough, reliable, and compliant.

Here are a few of the factors that separate effective background checks from ineffective background checks.

  • Effective background checks encompass multiple types of checks.

The employers with the most effective background check policies typically use multiple different background checks to learn more about their candidates. Those checks might include multiple criminal history searches—of county recordsstate repositoriesfederal criminal records, and multi-jurisdictional databases. They might include address histories or alias checks. They might include verifications of resume details like educationwork history, and professional licenses or certifications. They might encompass other checks for things like driving records and credit history.

There is no one database that incorporates all the information that you are likely looking for with a pre-employment background check. As such, to have an effective background check policy, you will need to run multiple checks spanning all different categories.

  • Effective background checks are run by reputed background check companies.

As a rule, background checks cost money. A single pre-employment background check might involve traveling to county courthouses to source records, paying fees to access records, calling former employers or university offices, and other steps. The process takes time, skill, and knowledge of the protocol and process of accessing public record information.

Bottom line, you get what you pay for with background checks. If you run a background check through a free online database, you aren’t going to get much. If you hire a skilled and reputed background check company to conduct your background checks for you, you are going to get much more accurate and detailed results.

  • Effective background checks comply with relevant laws and guidance.

When structuring your background check policy, remember that finding details about a candidate’s past is not the only thing that you need to worry about. It is important to comply with all relevant laws, ordinances, industry regulations, and other forms of guidance that may apply to your business.

You will need to follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act to the letter and take note of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission guidance. Comply with ban the box ordinances, laws about using arrest records in hiring decisions, and other relevant laws that may differ state to state. At, we have a Learning Center designed to help employers understand the rules and limitations of compliant background checks.


How effective are background checks? If your background check policy covers the three areas discussed above, then it can and should be very effective. If it doesn’t, you risk overlooking important information (or stumbling into a legal quagmire). Trust to help you launch a smart, effective, and compliant employee screening strategy.



Tag Cloud
Recent Posts

Latest News

  • August 15 Background checks aren't a silver bullet that solves every concern about prospective new hires—they are a tool that must be used with care. How can an incorrect approach lead to inadequate vetting? 
  • August 13 How has legislation and regulation changed the way employers use criminal background checks? We look at some of the rules that modern companies must follow.
  • August 08 With many industries facing labor shortages, advocates and legislatures are reconsidering policies that exclude potential employees. Expansion of record expungement and "ban the box" rules could change the system. 
  • August 06 Continuous background screening or ongoing criminal monitoring is the best way to keep track of critical new developments on an employee’s criminal record. Learn how these background checks work. 
  • August 01

    A new lawsuit filed in New York alleges that department store chain Macy’s ignored federal hiring guidelines and laws, firing individuals for old and non-job-related criminal convictions. 


  • July 30 The Minneapolis City Council is considering a series of ordinances that would regulate the use of tenant background checks and security deposits. The city’s tight housing market has made it difficult for individuals with bad credit, eviction histories, or criminal records to find housing.
  • July 25 Following revelations about wrongdoing in USA Gymnastics at the hands of team doctor Larry Nasser, sports organizations must grapple with how to safeguard their members. Some have found more success than others. 
  • July 24 What do landlords want to know before accepting new tenants? Here are the basics included in the average tenant background check.
  • July 23 7-Eleven will pay nearly $2 million to settle a class-action lawsuit concerning its background check process. The lawsuit alleges that the convenience store chain violated the FCRA with its background check disclosure document.
  • July 22 Social and child service organization rely on background checks to vet employees, sponsors, drivers, and other staff members and volunteers. By helping to root out histories of violence, sexual abuse, and other red flags, our resources assist these organizations in keeping the people they serve safe.